- Under $25
Wooden tool kit
A hammer, a wrench, a screwdriver and a box of wooden nuts and bolts. A 4-year-old helper can follow the grown-up with the real toolbox.
- Under $25
Reusable sticker scenes
Peel the people and cars off a town scene and put them somewhere new, again and again. A different story every time.
- Under $25
Pretend flower garden set
Plant play seeds in spongy soil, spray them with water and watch the petals change color as if they bloomed. A garden in the middle of winter.
- Under $25
Kid-size watering can
A real job: the houseplants. Fill it halfway and let them make the rounds every watering day.
- Under $25
Cooperative goose game
Players work together instead of against each other, and the game gets them up and moving. A gentle first game for a child who hates to lose.
- Under $25
Picture memory game
Turn over two tiles and remember where the match was hiding. Short rounds suit a short attention span, and anyone at the table can win.
- Under $25
Wooden animal stacking game
Roll the die, add an animal to the wobbly pile and hope it holds. Big laughs when it tumbles, and then everyone builds again.
- Under $25
Cars and Trucks and Things That Go
Richard Scarry's busy picture book has something silly in every corner and a tiny goldbug to find on each page.
- Under $25
Corduroy, a picture book
A teddy bear in green overalls goes looking for his lost button. By the third reading, a 4-year-old can tell you what happens next.
- Under $25
Kid's flashlight
For leading the walk to see the neighbors' lights, or checking under the bed. The one we found is made for ages 4 and up.
- Under $25
Paint-your-own wooden magnets
Paint wooden butterflies, then stick them on the fridge to hold up the next drawing. Most 4-year-olds draw people now, so expect portraits.
- $25 to $75
Wooden figure-8 train set
Like the set under the tree in the picture: wooden track, an engine with a coal car and a bridge to go over. Push power only, no batteries.
- $25 to $75
Role-play costume set
A chef's hat, a doctor's coat or a hard hat. The CDC's examples of 4-year-old pretend play include a teacher, a superhero and a dog.
- $25 to $75
Pet vet play set
A plush dog and cat, a stethoscope, bandages and a cast for a sore paw. Looking after someone smaller is a favorite job at four.
- $25 to $75
Cooperative orchard game
Everyone picks fruit together before the raven reaches the orchard. Rolling a die and taking turns are the only skills it needs.
- $25 to $75
Three-wheel scooter and a helmet
Three wheels help with balance while they learn to steer. The scooter we checked is made for ages 3 and up, and the helmet goes on every ride.
- $25 to $75
Gear-building set
Build machines from big and small gears, then turn one to watch the others spin. Made for ages 3 and up.
- $25 to $75
Pop-up soccer goal and ball
Kick, score, cheer, repeat. The CDC says most 4-year-olds catch a large ball most of the time, and a goal adds kicking to the game.
- $25 to $75
Butterfly garden with a caterpillar voucher
Unwrap the habitat at Christmas and send for the caterpillars when spring comes, then watch them turn into butterflies. Made for ages 4 and up.
- $25 to $75
Kid-size broom, mop and duster
Liking to be a helper is a 4-year-old milestone, the CDC says. A broom their own size makes sweeping up after dinner their job.
- $25 to $75
Stamp-and-sort mailbox
Write a letter (scribbles count), stamp it, sort it and deliver it. The mail carrier game ends with real cards for the family.
- $25 to $75
Hopscotch rug
Hop, land, count and hop again, indoors on a long winter afternoon. No chalk to wash off the floor.
- $25 to $75
Camper tent play set
A play tent shaped like a camper van, with a door and windows, for road trips that never leave the living room. Pack snacks and the flashlight.
- $25 to $75
Wooden gingerbread house set
Build it, decorate it with wooden candies and icing cords, take it apart and build it again. A gingerbread house nobody can eat by New Year's.
- $75 and up
Wooden workbench with tools
A bench their height with a working vise, a hammer, a saw and dozens of wooden screws and nails. Every fix-it job gets a helper.
- $75 and up
Puppet theater
Put on a show of a story they know by heart, with hand puppets or socks with drawn-on faces. They tell the story; you clap.
- $75 and up
Train table with storage
The track stays up between games instead of going back in the box every night. A next step for a child who loves the train set.
- $75 and up
Wooden café counter
Take orders from the menu board, make pretend lattes and cocoa, and swipe the play card at the register. Grown-ups make excellent customers.
- $75 and up
Youth zoo membership
Some zoos sell memberships for children, apart from the family plan. A year of visits shows them the same animals in every season.
- $75 and up
First pedal bike
A 16-inch bike made for ages 4 to 6, plus a helmet. Check the maker's height chart before you buy, so their feet reach the ground.